Bu John Gilstrap
Another brave soul has stepped up to the plate and volunteered for a First Page Critique. The Italics are all mine, just to separate the author’s text from my comments, which appear on the far side. Here we go . . .
NUTTER BODEEN
’tis a gift to be simple, ’tis a gift to be free
Eighteenth century Shaker song
“I think I killed someone.”
Not what Police Chief Will Edd Pruitt wanted or needed to hear first thing on a scorching hot Monday morning with the department’s A/C on the fritz. He’d positioned an oscillating fan next to his desk, but it only made his small office feel like a convection oven.
He silently cursed Jim Beam for last night, and waited for the caffeine and four aspirins to kick in. His eyes hurt as he tried to focus on the giant standing in the doorway to his office. He was shirtless, wore faded, grime-stained bib overalls meant for a much smaller person, and his sockless feet were stuffed into laceless brogans. His square head reminded Will Edd of Boris Karloff in the old Frankenstein movie.
Out at his desk, Gus Temple, made the “crazy” sign with his finger, careful to make sure the big man didn’t see him. Will Ed frowned at him, but the skinny dispatcher just grinned.
His name was Arvil LeRoy Bodeen, and he wasn’t crazy, just slow—— the result of a teen-age mother who consoled her unwanted pregnancy by snorting meth and drinking cheap wine. His eyes darted nervously around the room like a frightened kid on his first visit to the dentist.
Will Edd took a sip from his warm Dr. Pepper, sighed and said, “Come on in, Arvil.”
Arvil LeRoy Bodeen lumbered in and plopped down in the visitor’s chair. It groaned in protest. In the closeness of the room, the smell that rolled off him was a mixture of cheap booze, old vomit and unwashed armpits. Will Ed scooted his chair back as far as he could and tried to breathe through his mouth.
“My friends call me Nutter,” Arvil Leroy Bodeen said, his voice seeming too high pitched for his massive body. “You can too, if you want.”
Will Ed doubted the man had any friends. He frightened the women and scared the men. Over the years, the town had learned to accept him as they would a stray mongrel—— let it sleep under your porch, but never let it into the house.
“How ‘bout I just call you Arvil?”
“Okay, but you can still be my friend.”
First the good:
There’s a lot here to like. The first line is everything a first line should be. It’s short, to the point and engaging. I get a real sense of place, a sense of atmosphere. The writing is journeyman like (that’s a compliment), though it needs tightening (see below). It’s a compelling setup. If the point of a first page is to drive the reader to turn to the second page, then this is a success. Except . . .
Now let’s talk about strengthening the already-strong writing:
Not what Police Chief Will Edd Pruitt wanted or needed to hear first thing on a scorching hot Monday morning with the department’s A/C on the fritz. He’d positioned an oscillating fan next to his desk, but it only made his small office feel like a convection oven.
- Is his middle name Edd or Ed? You present it both ways.
- Pruitt just heard some startling news, yet he’s more concerned about the heat and the fan. I’m not sure I buy it, but I’m thinking like a critiquer (critic?), not a reader. If this were from an author I liked, it would not be a deal breaker because I would assume that the author wanted me to think Pruitt is something of a prick. If that’s not your point, consider changing it.
- “Scorching hot” is superfluously redundant. Pick one, drop the other.
- “He’d positioned…” Who’s “he”?
He silently cursed Jim Beam for last night, and waited for the caffeine and four aspirins to kick in. His eyes hurt as he tried to focus on the giant standing in the doorway to his office. He was shirtless, wore faded, grime-stained bib overalls meant for a much smaller person, and his sockless feet were stuffed into laceless brogans. His square head reminded Will Edd of Boris Karloff in the old Frankenstein movie.
- The adverb in the first sentence weakens it, and the second part of the sentence weakens it further. Consider: “He cursed Jim Beam for last night. The caffeine and four aspirins hadn’t kicked in yet.” Maybe it’s just my style, but I think breaking the one sentence into two strengthens them both.
- I think you need to give the giant man a name in this paragraph. Consider: “. . . in the doorway. Arvil LeRoy Bodeen. He was . . .” Note I deleted “to his office” because we already know that.
- Sentence construction that begins, “He was . . .” is inherently weak. Consider, “Shirtless, he’d stuffed his sockless feet into laceless brogans. Faded, grime-stained bib overalls barely contained the man’s girth, making Will Edd wonder if the man had dressed himself in someone else’s clothes.” By eliminating the passive voice, the images become more vivid and the prose snaps a little more.
His name was Arvil LeRoy Bodeen, and he wasn’t crazy, just slow—— the result of a teen-age mother who consoled her unwanted pregnancy by snorting meth and drinking cheap wine. His eyes darted nervously around the room like a frightened kid on his first visit to the dentist.
- By introducing Arvil’s name earlier, you eliminate the need for more passive construction. Consider: “Arvil wasn’t crazy, just slow . . .”
- This whole sentence, from Pruitt’s POV, presumes knowledge of backstory that doesn’t jibe with future paragraphs. Knowing about the unwanted pregnancy and the meth is pretty personal stuff.
- I would end the final sentence of this graph at “room”. The simile about the frightened kid seems over-worked. (That is a simile, right?)
Arvil LeRoy Bodeen lumbered in and plopped down in the visitor’s chair. It groaned in protest. In the closeness of the room, the smell that rolled off him was a mixture of cheap booze, old vomit and unwashed armpits. Will Ed scooted his chair back as far as he could and tried to breathe through his mouth.
- More passive construction. Not bad, per se, but not strong to my ear. Consider: “A toxic bouquet of cheap booze, old vomit and unwashed armpits made Will Edd’s eyes water. He scooted . . .”
“My friends call me Nutter,” Arvil Leroy Bodeen said, his voice seeming too high pitched for his massive body. “You can too, if you want.”
Will Ed doubted the man had any friends. He frightened the women and scared the men. Over the years, the town had learned to accept him as they would a stray mongrel—— let it sleep under your porch, but never let it into the house.
“How ‘bout I just call you Arvil?”
“Okay, but you can still be my friend.”
- This is the part that confuses me. Does the chief know him or not? That equation needs to be equalized somehow.
- Also, is it necessary to use all three of Arvil’s names at every mention? It feels awkward to me.
Fearless Writer, congratulations on a fine start. These edits are of a polishing nature. You done good.
What say you, TKZers?