The First Mystery Novel

“The job of the artist is always to deepen the mystery.” —Francis Bacon

* * *

Kris Montee wrote a post last week about mystery novels and authors. Today, Dale Ivan Smith and I begin a two-part post on the first mystery novel, The Woman in White by Wilkie Collins. In this post, I’ll explore the background of the novel and give a summary of the plot. In his upcoming post, Dale will take a look at the characters in the book.

BACKGROUND

Wilkie Collins was born in England in 1824. His father was the  well-known artist William Collins. Authors will be interested to know that it was Wilkie’s experience at Cole’s boarding school where he first found an incentive for telling stories. According to a Collins biography website:

It was here that he began his career as a storyteller to appease the dormitory bully, later recalling that ‘it was this brute who first awakened in me, his poor little victim, a power of which but for him I might never have been aware.’

Attorneys (and I know there are some that read these posts) will be interested to know Collins was a law student and was called to the bar in 1851. Although he never practiced law, his tendency to describe events in some of his books through the eyes of different characters, reminds one of witness testimonies.

Collins’ friendship with Charles Dickens began around 1850. The first of Collins’ four major novels, The Woman in White, was published in serial form in Dickens’ All the Year Round periodical from November 1859 to August 1860 and became a roaring success.  Again, from the Collins biography website:

It was received with great popular acclaim and ran to seven editions in 1860, alone. All kinds of commodities such as cloaks, bonnets, perfumes were called after it; there were Woman in White Waltzes and Quadrilles; it was parodied in Punch; Gladstone found the story so absorbing that he missed a visit to the theatre; and Thackeray was engrossed from morning to sunset.

Perhaps the extraordinary popularity of the novel was why Collins left instructions for his tombstone to be inscribed with the words “In memory of Wilkie Collins, author of ‘The Woman in White’ and other works of fiction.”

A NEW GENRE

You would think the first effort at a new genre would be a clumsy one, but I didn’t find that when I read the book. Although it’s long (248K words according to howlongtoread.com), the story is captivating, and it is considered by many to be one of the best novels ever written. This from Wikipedia:

In 2003, Robert McCrum writing for The Observer listed The Woman in White number 23 in “the top 100 greatest novels of all time,” and the novel was listed at number 77 on the BBC’s survey The Big Read.

At its heart, TWIW is a love story. Boy meets girl, boy loses girl, boy gets girl back. But the story is wrapped within a mysterious “secret” that the main character pursues and it’s this that keeps the reader turning pages.

PLOT AND STRUCTURE

The book is divided into three “epochs” which are narrated by different characters.

In Epoch One, Collins immediately employs The Hook. The protagonist, a young art instructor by the name of Walter Hartright, is approached while alone on a dark road by a mysterious woman in distress who is dressed all in white.

The woman, Anne Catherick, asks for directions, and Hartright helps her find a cab to take her to her destination. In the next few paragraphs, Hartright witnesses a man in a carriage tell a policeman that a woman escaped from his asylum. She was dressed all in white! Now the reader is hooked for sure.

Hartright continues to his new position at Limmeridge House where he meets his students, half-sisters Marian Halcombe and Laura Fairlie. They live in the estate home of Laura’s uncle and guardian, the hilarious curmudgeon, Mr. Fairlie. Hartright notices Laura bears a striking resemblance to the woman in white, and he tells them the story of his meeting with Anne Catherick.

Walter and Laura fall in love, but Laura, who will receive a large sum of money upon marriage, is engaged to be married to Sir Percival Glyde, a man she does not love. Hartright is forced into a heartbreaking withdrawal.

When Glyde arrives at the estate prior to the marriage, he seems genial enough, but there’s something edgy and uncomfortable about him. The young women discover he was responsible for committing Anne Catherick to a mental institution.

Percival Glyde and Laura Fairlie marry, and it soon becomes apparent that he wants her to sign over her inheritance to him. Tension builds between Laura and Percival. The stakes are further raised when Anne Catherick appears again and indicates she has a secret about Percival Glyde that will destroy him, but she doesn’t reveal it.

By the time Walter Hartright reenters the story, he is told Laura is dead and Anne Catherick has been sent back to a mental institution. Marian Halcombe is convinced foul play was involved in Laura’s death, and she and Hartright begin an amateur sleuth investigation into the situation. They are especially interested in the “secret” Anne Catherick had. They track Anne to an asylum where they make a shocking discovery.

I’ll stop there so I don’t give away the ending.

* * *

I mentioned several of the major characters above, but there are ten characters that offer first person accounts at different points in the story. Although we sometimes think we need to limit the number of POV characters, I think the “witness” narratives are effective here. In my opinion, having the story emerge through the eyes of various characters is an effective way to put the puzzle together one piece at a time until the reader finally gets to see the whole picture.

* * *

There are several movies of The Woman in White. The one we have is the Masterpiece Theatre version, and I recommend it. The acting is very good. Although the movie changes some of the story and shortens it considerably, it’s a great introduction to TWIW.

* * *

So TKZers: Have you read The Woman in White or seen any of the various movies? What are your thoughts? Have you used the method of telling a story through the eyes of different characters? What’s your favorite mystery novel?

 

  Cassie Deakin investigates a forty-year-old murder mystery and comes face-to-face with a killer who will stop at nothing to keep his secret.

Available at  AmazonBarnes & NobleKoboGoogle Play, or Apple Books.

12 thoughts on “The First Mystery Novel

  1. Thanks for this intriguing intro to TWIW, Kay. It’s been on my TBR list b/c it’s the first mystery novel, but I haven’t gotten around it. Now I’m motivated to put it at the top of the pile.

    Looking forward to Dale’s part 2.

    • Good morning, Debbie!

      I look forward to hearing your opinion of the book. I do wonder if Collins wrote the entire thing and then contributed one piece at a time to Dickens’ periodical. Or if he wrote and contributed each section separately. Either way, it was a monumental effort.

      Have a good week.

  2. Thanks for your insights, Kay. Like so many others, I downloaded The Woman in White from Project Gutenberg, where it got filed with other free copies of books and scripts. You’ve inspired me to blow off the digital dust and get to reading!

  3. I found The Woman in White in a London bookshop when I was a teenager. I don’t even remember what made me buy it, considering it’s old and English is not my native language. I think it was the title. Once I started reading it, I couldn’t stop. I read every day after school long into the night, the dictionary always next to me (no smartphones and no online dictionaries yet…). It’s one of my favorite books and definitely the best mystery I’ve read – it’s haunting, thrilling, extremely well-written, and the different witnesses are characterized so well and so distinctly different you can hardly believe they’ve sprung out of the same author’s pen. The way they talk, think, and act – you’d think they actually exist. The puzzle resulting from all these individual accounts is really what made this book so fascinating.

    • That’s a great recollection, Lilly. I had wondered if people would read TWIW in today’s world because of its length. Like you, I started reading and couldn’t stop. I also think the individual accounts enhance the telling of the story.

      Thanks for sharing your experience.

  4. I’ll definitely read The Woman in White after the glowing description. I’m a big fan of some British mystery writers such as Sir Conan Doyle and Dorothy L. Sayers. Gaudy Night stands out for me as an excellent study in creating memorable characters and a puzzle-like mystery.

    • I’m also a fan of many British mystery writers, including Dorothy Sayers.

      I’ll be interested to hear what you think about The Woman in White, Kelly.

  5. Wow, Kay. You put a lot of work into Part I of this fascinating series, and it shows. Years ago, I saw a movie entitled The Woman in White, but I don’t recall if it was based on the book. Also didn’t realize TWIW was the first mystery novel. Great job today! Thank you.

    • Hi Sue. Thanks for the kind words.

      It was Dale’s idea for us to do a joint post on TWIW, but we’ve both been too busy to get into it until now. Doing the research into the life of Wilkie Collins and the publication of the book was a lot of fun.

      i’m looking forward to Dale’s post on the characters.

  6. Now I have to read The Woman in White! All of this was very fascinating! I have a subscription to BritTV and watch quite a few programs on there…when I can get the closed caption to work. lol

    • Hi Patricia. I found the background of the book to be fascinating, so let me know if you read it.

      If you get a chance to see the Masterpiece Theatre version of the story, I think you’ll like it. It’s a lot shorter and more to the taste of modern mystery readers.

Comments are closed.