Colorful Author Johnny Worthen

by Debbie Burke

 

Johnny Worthen author photo

Multi-genre author Johnny Worthen is a colorful character, both literally and figuratively. For his talk at the October Colorado Gold conference, he appeared barefoot, wearing a bright tie-dyed t-shirt reminiscent of the psychedelic ’60s. The tie-dye theme repeats on his business card and website, complete with photos and video of him goofing around.

It’s not a stretch to imagine Johnny in school as the class smartass. I’m guessing he drove his teachers crazy yet also earned their grudging respect because of his obvious intelligence and insatiable hunger to learn.

He graduated magna cum laude from the University of Utah and recalls: “Armed with two humanities degrees, I naturally gravitated to the food service industry.”

Similar ironic humor comes through his entire presentation along with his social media posts.

His website logline states: “I write what I like to read. That guarantees me at least one fan.”

At a later-in-life crossroads, he chucked his previous careers and experience to take up writing professionally. His work spans multiple genres: sci-fi, YA, humor, horror, mystery, and upmarket fiction. His appetite for continuous learning also led him back to his alma mater where he now teaches creative writing, sparking similar desires in his students.

Johnny’s opinions are as vivid as his tie-dyed wardrobe yet also down to earth and well-grounded in classical literature.

To open his talk, he immediately punctured glamorous illusions about writing: “Writing is not a profession. It’s a trade.” A trade, he says, that one learns by doing, not studying.

The topic of his presentation was subtext, exploring the meaning that lies beneath the surface of what’s being said on the page.

He cites surprising statistics: only seven percent of communication is verbal; 38% is tone of voice; 55% is body language, adding up to 93%. The overwhelming weight of communication is non-verbal.

His teaching style demonstrates those statistics. He asks a question. Next, he darts to and fro around the room, scanning for people who raise their hands. Then he stops in front of a person, pins them with an intense gaze, and gestures for them to answer. When they respond, he rewards them with a fist-bump or other non-verbal encouragement.

He likens subtext to Hemingway’s “iceberg theory” about dialogue. It’s the “theory of omission,” where implied elements and negative space convey the meaning of a story more effectively than words on the page.

The example he cited was the short story, “Hills Like White Elephants,” where a couple talks about a number of subjects while avoiding the most critical topic: the abortion they’re considering. The words pregnancy and abortion are never spoken out loud, but they permeate every sentence.

Johnny believes reading has never been a passive endeavor. A book requires interaction: writers create scenes that readers in turn visualize. Those scenes come to life in the reader’s own imagination.

He contrasts that experience with videos that require no interaction. A movie or TV show can play in the background whether or not anyone is watching.

Subtext can be direct or indirect, shown with irony and contrast. He refers to The Godfather as a classic example. During the baptism ceremony, while Michael Corleone vows to renounce Satan and all his works, at the same moment, jump cuts show Michael’s henchmen carrying out his orders to exterminate his gang rivals.

In the mystery genre, subtext contains clues and pieces that will ultimately solve the crime. Part of the reader’s enjoyment of mysteries is trying to fit the disparate pieces of the puzzle together. When they figure out the puzzle, they feel smart. When they don’t figure out the solution, they admire the author’s skill at misdirecting them. Either way, they’re satisfied.

Johnny laments that today’s readers often want to be spoon-fed. He’s annoyed that they don’t want to do any work to understand the meaning of a story. They want to be TOLD what’s going on, rather than figure it out for themselves based on what the author SHOWS.

He attributes much of that lack of attention to “second screen viewing.” People are often watching a film or TV show at the same time they’re scrolling on their phones. Because they’re distracted by the second screen, they need to be constantly reminded what’s going on in the film.

Johnny believes humans are “meaning-making machines.” Asking the question why is uniquely human. Animals simply accept circumstances and find ways to survive them. In contrast, humans are driven to ask why circumstances happened. Why did someone behave that way? What is the meaning behind actions and events? Why does one exist in this universe? What is the meaning and purpose of one’s life?

Early in his life, Johnny recognized words not only led him to answers but also more questions in a never-ending chain reaction. Curiosity leads to learning that leads to answers that lead to new questions.

Today, he asks those questions of others, guiding them to find their own answers in their own words.

At the bottom of Johnny’s website, he poses one last burning question:

“Why Tie-Dye? I was told at my first Grateful Dead show that you wear tie-dye not for yourself but for your friends. You’re welcome.”

Thanks, Johnny, for asking questions that caused me to ask more questions!

***

Learn more about Johnny Worthen, his books, appearances, teaching, and his tie-dyed wardrobe at his website.

***

TKZers, do you include subtext in your stories? How do you handle the deeper meaning behind the written word?

***

Learn how to master subtext for villains and antagonists in Debbie Burke’s award-winning book:

The Villain’s Journey-How to Create Villain’s Readers Love to Hate.

 

Subtext – Guest Post by Karen Albright Lin

By Debbie Burke

@burke_writer

 

Karen Albright Lin

Back in the 1990s, author/editor Karen Lin and I met at the Rocky Mountain Fiction Writers Conference. We hit it off immediately and have remained good friends even though we rarely see each other except via Zoom.

Karen is the author of American Moon, a moving saga about the immigration of her Chinese in-laws, and MuShu Mac & Cheese, a humorous mash-up of Julia Child and My Big Fat Chinese Wedding.

She also teaches writing online, at conferences, and even on cruise ships–a tough gig but somebody’s gotta do it!

The following is an excerpt from a two-week class on Subtext that Karen will teach beginning April 10th through Scribophile. Membership to the huge online critique group is free.

Subtext is an advanced technique that adds depth and resonance to writing. I invited Karen to share her excellent tips with TKZ.

Welcome, Karen!

~~~

Subtext in Dialogue /Body Language — Gestures/Posture/Mannerisms/Actions/Facial Expressions

Photo credit: Pexels

 Simply stated:

If dialogue is about what the dialogue is about, you’re in trouble.

People don’t always say what they mean outright. In fact sometimes the words are in direct opposition to body language. Body language includes gestures, facial expressions, posture, mannerisms, and actions that communicate without words.

Subtext can come in the form of understatement, sarcasm, or a witty punchline, a result, often, of backloading your sentence. That means putting the most powerful word at the end of the sentence, or sentence at the end of a paragraph, or paragraph at the end of a chapter. Backloading is powerful for narrative also. It makes your words lean forward into the next thing. It teases and says to the reader, “Come along with me on this adventure.”

I mentioned punchlines; I should also warn you about them. If they aren’t really great and cleverly pulled off, they can fall flat.

Comedy is all about subtext turned inside out. A joke says what we’re all thinking. Comedic details are the key. Outlandish adjectives and sarcastic barbs right in the middle of a monologue are fun examples.

Dialogue can mask the character’s desires and necessities, but it still leaves clues about what is really meant behind the words. Sarcasm, Freudian slips, unexpected words, and irony are all techniques that can be used to hint at the truth.

Let’s look at an example of emotionally charged dialogue in the movie Carol, Cate Blanchett’s character doesn’t come right out and ask if Therese finds her pretty.

Carol asks, “Were those pictures of me you were taking at the tree lot?” (Subtext: “You find me beautiful?”)

Therese replies, “Sorry, I should have asked.” (Subtext: “Is it OK for me to be attracted to you?”)

Carol says, “Don’t apologize,” (Subtext: “You don’t need to ask for permission to be attracted to me, even though I’m a woman”)

On the surface it is a conversation about photos. It is actually about their sexual desire for each other. The secondary message doesn’t tell it directly.

Use vernacular to tell us about a person. Is he educated? Irish? a braggart?

The most common flaw I see in dialogue is when the characters speak in robotic information-load rather than how real people talk. It suggests the reader wouldn’t get it otherwise. Trust your reader. The challenge is to NOT write “on-the-nose” dialogue, while still revealing important information to the audience. Resist spelling everything out in an expository way. You encourage the readers to come to you BECAUSE you are giving them credit.

For the perfect lesson on subtext in dialogue watch Annie Hall, written by Woody Allen. As Annie and Alvie talk, the subtext in their discussion is written on the screen with subtitles. Their verbal discussion is about photography. In the subtext she’s wondering if she’s smart enough for him. He’s wondering if he’s too shallow. She wonders if he’s a shmuck like other men. He wonders what she looks like naked.

Woody Allen teaches us that characters can talk about anything as long as the true message comes across, as long as the scene accomplishes its purpose. First understand the intention of the scene, then write the dialogue with rich subtext to fulfill that need.

In a real conversation and excellent dialogue (with no subtitles for comic effect) ideas are not spelled out directly, every thought, every feeling stated. Good dialogue reveals without doing that.

Does a person’s private life and public life look the same? Will they say the opposite of what they mean to disguise who they are?

Dialogue was never intended to replicate real speech. It represents attitudes and what the character wants, an outpouring of secrets the character wishes not to disclose.

If you want to study good dialogue, study successful plays. Imagine a middle-aged couple arguing over whether to outfit their new bedroom with two single beds or their old double bed. On the surface the fight is over beds. But in subtext, they reveal their whole marriage, facing what has happened to their lives and love over so many years.

Here are two bits of dialogue. This conversation is between two wealthy friends, one unsure about his future. Which version draws you in as a reader? Which one spells out too much, unsubtly, doing all the work for the reader?

Jack lined up another shot as Kyle looked on. “Dad wants me to take over his backup generator company.”

Vincent smirked as Jack’s ball spun down into the billiards pocket. “So? What’s the problem?”

“Everything! I know he wants to keep it all in the family but I just graduated from CU with honors. I want to make my way in the world on my own.”

Now read this version:

 Vincent looked on as Jack pummeled a ball into the pocket. ”Something bothering you, man?”

“Four years gone.” Jack frowned. “And for what? Okay, it was fun, but…”

“At least Daddy’ll give you a nice office.”

The reader must infer information in the second version. In the first version the writer outright states it upfront in an on-the-nose way. It can be a tough skill to master. When reading a good quality novel, notice how a character is revealed through dialogue and how short and sharp most conversations are.

As suggested by our parents and kindergarten teachers, often actions speak louder than words. Experiment with this. Don’t state your point.

In Charles Dickens’s A Tale of Two Cities a character volunteers to be beheaded. That is how he says “I love you.” Much more powerful, right?

Some things go without saying. They are inferred rather than spoken. Don’t discount the powerful sound of silence.

Body Language

Photo credit: Pexels

That brings us to the subject of body language. Just as in real life, one can say a lot through their gestures, posture, actions, facial expressions, and mannerisms. Think of it as coded language.

These are also fun ways to create dynamic dialogue tags. You could use a plain simple tag:

“You don’t really care about my headache,” she said.

Or you could try:

“You don’t really care about my headache.” She turned, tempted to throw a few pieces of fine china at him.

In Terminator Arnold Schwarzenegger doesn’t say, “Watch your back. I’m still a threat to you.” Instead he says, “I’ll be back.” (The subtext: remember I’m a threat as you learned from my previous actions and dialogue) These three words add tension, raise questions about the future, and make the audience hungry for more, especially into the sequel. You want to do that with your novel, especially if you are writing a series.

The dialogue is snappy and indirect. If it had been on-the-nose, it wouldn’t be as powerful. It would have spit the meaning at the audience rather than engaging them. “I’ll be back” stayed one step away from the actual meaning.

In The Great Gatsby we have this slice of dialogue:

“I’ve got a man in England who buys me clothes.  He sends over a selection of things at the beginning of each season, spring and fall.”

Is this really about clothes? No. It is about wealth.

Another example:

A 4th grade boy trudges his way to the front of the room and slips his paper onto Ms. Garcia’s desk.

After looking through two pages, she asks, “Are you sure you want to turn this in?”

What’s the subtext?  What’s the trudging mean? What does the teacher’s dialogue mean?

~~~

Karen, thanks for guesting and for giving TKZ an advance peek!

~~~

TKZers: Do you use subtext in your writing? How do you avoid on-the-nose dialogue?