Greetings, thrill seekers. We have another first page for critique. Give it a read and join me on the other side.
Title: PROTECTED PERSONS. Genre: Thriller.
PART ONE — NATURAL CAUSES
Prologue
Davos, Switzerland. 11:40. Pulse 61.
The Prime Minister of Canada has nine minutes to live, and he is going to spend one of them on a joke.
His name is Marc Delorme. I watch him on a television with the sound off, in a cheap hotel room across town from the World Economic Forum. It is late January. The clock in the corner of the screen says twenty to twelve.
I know when he will die because I chose the minute: eleven forty-nine, in the main hall, four minutes before the end of his speech.
The voice in my head does not choose the names, or the minute. I do. It came to me in a hospital, in a white room, after a bomb, when I could not move my hands or remember my own name. It still comes with a hum behind my left ear, low and steady, like a fridge in an empty flat. It never tells me who. Mostly it says the same few sentences it has always said, in the even voice of someone reading out a rule.
Those who stand in the way must be removed.
It must look like nature.
What they meant to say must not be heard.
The rest is my work. The newspapers tell me who stands in the way, and they are very helpful about it. They print it every week, with photographs: a face at a lectern, announcing that his country will build a network of its own and need nobody else’s. In the way of what, the voice has never said. I was a soldier for a long time, and a soldier with clear orders sleeps well.
***
JSB: We have here a promising opening salvo for an international thriller. It has a Day of the Jackal type feel. The First Person Present POV, if it holds for the entire book (I’m guessing it does not) presents some challenges (which are beyond the scope of this post). For one thing, it prevents cross-cutting to other POVs for suspense purposes. Well, not always. You can certainly mix POVs, using First Person for one character, and Third Person for others. James Patterson has done this, and he’s sold a few books.
But today we’re looking at this first page and our question is: would I want to read on?
With some tweaks, my answer is yes. So let’s tweak.
We’ve talked about prologues several times here at TKZ. See here, here, and here.
Critique group chatter often holds that editors and agents don’t like prologues, so never use them. Tush. A prologue can make a great hook if it is a scene that works well on its own.
In the past I’ve counseled writers not to use the label Prologue. Just give us the scene with no heading, then do Chapter 1 next (as in Harlan Coben’s Tell No One). I read a thriller that started with 0 (a prologue scene), then came 1, 2, 3 etc.
Your book has Parts, so that’s necessary to label. My advice is to ditch the word Prologue.
That leaves you with the place/time stamp. That’s fine. I was thrown by Pulse 61 at first, then figured it’s the narrator describing his own. This seems needlessly confusing. If the guy is tracking his own pulse, let him tell us in the narrative. Maybe this is to be a recurring stamp. If so, I’d get tired of it.
The Prime Minister of Canada has nine minutes to live, and he is going to spend one of them on a joke.
I’d cut the last part. The Prime Minister of Canada has nine minutes to live. Boom. Let it stand alone. The part about the joke dilutes the impact.
His name is Marc Delorme. I watch him on a television with the sound off, in a cheap hotel room across town from the World Economic Forum. It is late January. The clock in the corner of the screen says twenty to twelve.
Good. You’ve given us the essential setting for the narrator, and main event, the World Economic Forum.
I know when he will die because I chose the minute: eleven forty-nine, in the main hall, four minutes before the end of his speech.
I’m interested. How has the narrator chosen the time, and how will he pull it off?
The voice in my head does not choose the names, or the minute. I do. It came to me in a hospital, in a white room, after a bomb, when I could not move my hands or remember my own name.
Good, marbled-in backstory. Some teachers say “No backstory in the opening!” I don’t subscribe to that. But I do counsel using it sparingly in the first few pages so it does not slow down the action. Here we have a guy who survived a bomb and gets a voice in his head. Voice? What’s that about? At this point it is a mystery, and that’s how I’d leave it for the moment. Unanswered questions are a great way to make a reader turn the page. You can reveal more about the voice later.
Give us some action now. You can save the rest of this page for later. But let’s have a look anyway:
It still comes with a hum behind my left ear, low and steady, like a fridge in an empty flat. It never tells me who. Mostly it says the same few sentences it has always said, in the even voice of someone reading out a rule.
Those who stand in the way must be removed.
It must look like nature.
What they meant to say must not be heard.
I like a fridge in an empty flat. That’s a great way to describe this mysterious voice.
For the three lines of the voice, I’d go ahead and use italics. Italics can be helpful, IMO, unless they come in big blocks. Yours do not. Italics would help readers “hear” the voice.
The rest is my work. The newspapers tell me who stands in the way, and they are very helpful about it. They print it every week, with photographs: a face at a lectern, announcing that his country will build a network of its own and need nobody else’s. In the way of what, the voice has never said. I was a soldier for a long time, and a soldier with clear orders sleeps well.
This paragraph is all exposition, and we don’t need it yet. My axiom is: Act first, explain later. What this first page needs is a character in motion, not in explanation.
All that said, I am intrigued. We have an impending assassination on a world stage, and a guy who hears a voice, and who is somehow going to make this happen. I would turn this page.
How about you, TKZers?
Thanks, Brave Author, for submitting. You had me intrigued from the place/time stamp. I have never before seen someone place a pulse rate in that line of detail and, being the geek I am, you made me curious so I had to go google what a normal pulse rate is for what I presumed to be an adult male. Google says males aged 18-25 have a normal pulse rate between 60-70, and the pulse rate starts at 62 for the next age bracket, 26-35 years. So you caused me to go into detective mode right from the start. Cool! (although he does say he was a soldier for a long time—that could theoretically be at odds with the 18-25 years of age potential assumption that I made of the POV character.)
I loved “like a fridge in an empty flat”
The cold methodical POV was very interesting. I’m not as experienced with thrillers but the one thing I was wondering while reading this submission is how will you maintain that first person POV throughout the story and keep readers guessing.
Also thought the line: “a soldier with clear orders sleeps well” was a good one.
With the opening line “The Prime Minister of Canada has nine minutes to live, and he is going to spend one of them on a joke.” This line intrigued me but my first reaction was “why am I being told this rather than seeing it?” BUT as I read the rest of the page I was very engaged because of how you’ve put together this cold, calculating POV.
I am definitely interested enough to turn the page.
I like the ‘and he’s going to spend one of them on a joke.” It’s sardonic/sarcastic and gives me an added insight into the “speaker’s” personality. He’s belitttling the target for making a joke–when the target doesn’t know what’s coming. I don’t read a lot of international thrillers, but I did like this open. As far as first person POV, I’ve written two women’s fiction novel in which three POV characters are first person present tense,(the chapters start with the character’s name in italic above the chapter & number heading) and a series of interspersed chapters that occur in the past are third person past tense. My agent is currently shopping the first one so we’ll see how it lands! (Feedback received from editors so far didn’t mention the POV or tense. Severn House came really close, but the editor had a problem with something one of the POV characters did so couldn’t “love” her. Sigh.)
Great job, Brave Author. I like your work very much. (I was going to say, “I like your voice,” but thought that might be confusing. 🙂 )
I don’t understand why some people say you should never use a prologue. I agree with Jim: if it serves the story, then use it.
The early sentence “The Prime Minister of Canada has nine minutes to live, and he is going to spend one of them on a joke” hooked me. Great juxtaposition of a life ending while the person is telling some trivial joke. Also loved the humming fridge simile.
I did get a little confused about what the “voice” was saying as opposed to the narrator. I like Jim’s suggestion to put the “voice” in italics. Also, I had to read the last paragraph a couple of times. It would be better to cut out most of that.
Although I don’t read a lot of thrillers, I most certainly would turn the page and continue reading this one. Thank you for submitting it.
This was very intriguing. I did like the part about the joke–like Kelly said, it gave insight into the POV character. Agree also that maintaining the 1st person, present tense would be difficult, but I suspect the author will switch to 3rd person close.
Let’s talk genre fiction and the impact listing the genre on a retail site might have on this well-written opening.
We have a couple of ‘suggested’ open mystery questions: Did the guy survive an explosion and, as a known trope, the guy suddenly has psionic powers? (Sub-genre would be paranormal thriller.) Did the guy survive an explosion, but as part of his life-saving treatment, did the military insert an experimental chip in his head that gives him psionic powers? (Sub-genre might be either military or technology thriller, maybe even political.) The military inserted an experimental chip in his head, but an AI has taken over control and is attempting to weed out anyone in power who might promote a competing AI. (Sub-genre leaning hard into technology thriller.)
Readers will know the sub-genre when they pick up the book, which will affect the mystery and suspense of what appear to be open questions in this isolated sample. Deciding how to list your book and what should be included in the blurb is always a gnarly question. Give some thought to how to keep the mystery going in light of information your reader may already have. And keep writing! You’re off to a great start.
Prologues are good if they’re relevant – and SHORT.
Mine are around 100-250 words, and the three volumes of the trilogy have a short prologue each, labeled ‘Prothalamion’ in honor of Dorothy L. Sayers (she uses that), and are paragraphs from a source OUTSIDE the main story, a (fake) article from The New Yorker claiming to explain the events in the story after they’re over, a style of retrospective article I’ve read there many a time. So the three prologues are a centering device for the reader, a hook, and a forewarning.
If the reader remembers anything from the prologues, they can see where the article is spot on – and where it completely misses the mark. I hope that’s fun and instructive.
If you have a complex layered story, prologues can be a bit of that complexity. Not all stories need or want that. I’d still keep them SHORT.
Twice through the first page. The hum is the strongest thing in it and the paragraph that names it is the weakest. By ‘The voice in my head does not choose the names, or the minute. I do,’ he has already handed over the rule, and everything after that is compliance. Let me watch him choose the minute before anyone tells me it comes with a hum.
‘It must look like nature’ does more work than the white room and the bomb. I would move it up and cut the hospital.
The last inch of an opening is not the hook. It is the line where you stop explaining how it works.